Thursday, 14 June 2012

MLB First Third Review - AL East


Baltimore Orioles (30-24; 2nd)

MVP: Adam Jones

The Orioles’ surprising start owes a lot to their pitching staff, which currently sports the 4th lowest team ERA in the American League. Why give the MVP to Jones then? In short, because he is the only regular player putting up consistent numbers. While the Orioles as a team rank near the middle of the AL in almost every offensive statistic (home runs aside), Jones is playing the best baseball of his career. Jones currently leads the team in runs, hits, home runs, RBIs, batting average and on-base percentage. Clearly, that contract extension was well-deserved.


Best Case Scenario:

Jones maintains his career year, while Nick Markakis, J.J. Hardy, and Matt Weiters all round in to form. Meanwhile their bullpen, anchored by Pedro Strop, Darren O’Day and closer Jim Johnson, continues to be one of the best in the majors. With the offense clicking, and the bullpen closing out late-inning situations, the Orioles patchwork rotation isn’t under too much pressure.

Worst Case Scenario:

Jones—and the rest of the team—return to their career norms, while the rest of the AL East rounds in to form, and takes turns beating up on the Orioles. This Orioles team has overachieved so far, making this scenario the most likely. Look for the O’s to fall off a bit in the second third of the season.

Boston Red Sox (28-26; 4th)

MVP: David Ortiz

While Red Sox fans are surely disappointed to this point of the season, Ortiz has been a definite bright spot. Like Adam Jones in Baltimore, Ortiz leads his teams’ offense in most significant categories (runs, home runs, slugging, average, RBIs…). This pick came down to Ortiz and Felix Doubront, who has been the most consistent starter in an otherwise underwhelming rotation. The fact that Doubront was even in the discussion points to how frustrating the Red Sox season has been thus far.

Best Case Scenario:

Health is the big thing for the Red Sox heading into the second third of the season. Jacoby Ellsbury, Kevin Youkilis, Dustin Pedroia, and of course Carl Crawford have all missed time. If Boston can get everyone healthy, this lineup becomes one of the deepest in the AL East. With this, the Red Sox need consistent pitching from their rotation, which has been disappointing so far.

Worst Case Scenario:

The pitching continues to struggle, and begins to dip into beer and fried chicken again, sabotaging the season. Marlon Byrd and Daniel Nava continue to get at-bats as the BoSox regulars can’t get healthy, and the team slowly fades.

Bottom Line:

It really does come down to health. If they’re healthy, there’s no way they continue to struggle.

New York Yankees (29-24; 3rd)

MVP: Derek Jeter

Once again, the Yankees’ are keeping pace with the rest of the AL thanks in large part to their offense. The difference, though, is that Derek Jeter—a notorious slow-starter—has come out of the gate blazing. He is hitting for average, getting on base, and even hitting for a little power, all while swiping 5 bags. If this continues, the big bats behind Jeter in the lineup should have plenty of RBI opportunities the rest of the season.
Number 2 has his Yanks in the thick of the AL East race

Best Case Scenario:

Like most years, the Yanks’ success this season will depend on their pitching. While Rafael Soriano has done a great job filling in for the injured Mariano Rivera, the rotation (which was supposed to be much-improved heading into the season) has been underwhelming. In this scenario, Phil Hughes and Ivan Nova rebound as we head into the summer, while Hiroki Kuroda and CC Sabathia gain consistency. The offense continues to roll.

Worst Case Scenario:

Hughes and Nova continue to give Yankees’ fans heart palpitations every five days, while the aging lineup begins to break down. Tampa Bay runs away with the division, while Boston gets healthy and makes a mid-summer push.

Bottom Line:

The Yankees should keep pace in the AL East, and make for an interesting race with Tampa Bay, and Boston.

Tampa Bay Rays

MVP: Fernando Rodney

Tampa leads the AL in team ERA. With that, consideration for this pick was given to David Price, the (now) undisputed ace of the staff. However, it is Rodney who has surprised to most. Seizing the closer role with Kyle Farnsworth hurt, Rodney has saved 17 games (in 18 opportunities), with sparkling numbers (1.03 ERA, 25:4 K/BB ratio, while holding opponents to a .172 batting average). Once thought too inconsistent to close games, Rodney has bounced back in a big way.

Best Case Scenario:

The pitching continues to be top-notch. The generally anemic offense picks it up in early summer (we’re talking about you Ben Zobrist). Perhaps most importantly, the surprisingly bad defense (currently ranking second-last in the AL) also improves.

Worst Case Scenario:

While the pitching maintains (let’s be honest its not going anywhere), the Rays just can’t score enough runs to beat the slugging Yanks and Sox. The defense continues to underwhelm, and the Rays slip into the middle of the division.

Bottom Line:

The Rays defense is not this bad. They’ve never blown people away with their offensive numbers, so as long as the pitching continues to be good, and the defense steadily improves, they will be really good.

Toronto Blue Jays

MVP: Edwin Encarnacion

A player for the Jays who recently patrolled the hot corner, is currently pacing them offensively, leading the team in home runs and RBI. Gotta be Jose Bautista, right? Wrong. Edwin Encarnacion has been the most consistent offensive player for the Jays this year, splitting time between DH and first base. If he can maintain this pace to some degree, he will be an amazing find for the Jays, a big bat that came out of nowhere.



Best Case Scenario:

Bautista starts playing like the Bautista of the last couple years, Encarnacion continues to be a power bat, Colby Rasmus ups his average, and Brett Lawrie starts hitting for a little more power. Ricky Romero and Brandon Morrow anchor the rotation, while arms like Drew Hutchison and Henderson Alvarez continue to pitch well enough to keep them in games.

Worst Case Scenario:

The bullpen continues to blow late leads, Bautista regresses to his 2004-2009 levels, and the rest of the kids don’t develop. This team relies a lot on youth, and if the young guys stall on their development, the team is in trouble.

Bottom Line:

This team is one of the toughest to project, since they rely so much on upside. While Bautista could very well regress a little, at least some of the young kids should pan out. Either way, they probably don’t have quite enough to keep up with the big boys in the AL East this year.

No comments:

Post a Comment