Thursday 14 June 2012

MLB First Third Review - AL Central


Chicago White Sox

MVP: Paul Konerko

Chris Sale deserves a shout out here. His WHIP is under 1.00, his ERA is under 3.00 (an AL-leading 2.30) and he is holding opponents to a batting average under .200. Those are ace numbers. Unfortunately, he doesn’t get the MVP for the ChiSox because Paul Konerko is playing out of his mind. He leads the team (and the AL) in batting average at .366, and is third in all of baseball with a 1.062 OPS. While the White Sox are playing well offensively as a whole, there is no doubt Konerko is sparking the whole thing.

Sale has been exceptional in his first season as a starter
Best Case Scenario:

Konerko continues his torrid pace, while youngsters Alejandro De Aza and Dayan Viciedo continue to impress with speed and power, respectively. Adam Dunn keeps hitting home runs (his average will never get into the .260 area where it once was), while Chris Sale and Jake Peavy continue to form a formidable top-2 in the rotation. Having Addison Reed develop into the elite closer he is projected to be would just be a bonus this year.

Worst Case Scenario:

Konerko cools off, the rest of the AL figures out De Aza and Viciedo, Dunn goes back to his 2011 production, and Sale’s elbow issues flare up again. If sale goes down, the rotation gets ridiculously thin, as Gavin Floyd, Phillip Humber and John Danks have all been terrible so far.

Bottom Line:

This division is totally up in the air at this point. The White Sox should be able to put up runs, so the team will really go as far as the pitching takes them.

Cleveland Indians
MVP: Jason Kipnis

Simply, the rookie second baseman has been the most exciting player for the Indians. His mix of speed and power, and his plus-ability on defense have secured him as the future of the Indians. If Cleveland are to stay in contention for the AL Central crown, though, Kipnis will have to maintain this pace, and avoid the slump so many rookies go through.

Best Case Scenario:

The rotation dramatically improves. That’s the big one. The Indians need Kipnis to maintain, and players like Shin-Soo Choo and Carlos Santana to match expectations, but the rotation picking it up has to be the primary goal going forward.

Worst Case Scenario:

The youngsters like Kipnis, Santana and center fielder Michael Brantley all slump, and the rotation continues to rank among the AL’s worst.

Bottom Line:This team just doesn’t feel like it has enough pieces to stay in the playoff hunt. Asdrubal Cabrera is a nice player, but he’ll have to dramatically improve his power numbers (harkening back to last year) for this offense to put enough runs on the board, countering the poor pitching.

Detroit Tigers

MVP(s): Miguel Cabrera, Prince Fielder

Fielder and Cabrera have thrived despite the Tigers' slow start

Yes, this is the obvious pick. But with a thus-far disappointing Tigers team, who else could claim the MVP? Verlander is having a (by his now-lofty standards) down season thus far, and by all statistical accounts, the Tigers are a team that doesn’t do anything particularly well. Then there are Cabrera and Fielder, who are doing exactly what we all expected: raking. Both players are hitting around .320, and slugging over .500. These two guys are doing exactly what they are paid the big bucks for, so they split the first-third MVP.

Best Case Scenario:

Austin Jackson returns from injury, providing the Tigers with a legitimate lead-off hitter, and table setter for Prince and Miggy. Verlander continues to be Verlander, while the rest of the rotation dramatically improves their production. The Tigers need better results out of the back end of their rotation to catch up to the White Sox.

Worst Case Scenario:

The team proves to be nothing more than two good bats, and one ace. They simply don’t have enough weapons to push for a playoff spot.

Bottom Line:

In all likelihood, the AL Central will come down to the Tigers and the White Sox. If some of the secondary pieces in Detroit can show up in the second half of the season, this team should push for a division crown.

Kansas City Royals

MVP: Billy Butler

While starter Felipe Paulino has been nothing short of dominant so far, the fact that he has only started a handful of games hurts his candidacy for MVP. Instead, the award goes to Billy Butler, who leads the team with a .297 average, 11 home runs, and 35 RBI. Butler has to be one of the most underrated sluggers in the league, thanks in large part to the fact he plays in Kansas City. While he may not get a ton of national coverage, Butler is once again having a stellar offensive year.

Best Case Scenario:

The Royals will not be in playoff contention by the time fall rolls around. Instead, they have to hope for continued development from their young players. If Felipe Paulino can continue his rise towards ace-status, and Eric Hosmer and Mike Moustakas steadily improve, this season will be considered a success.

Worst Case Scenario:

Paulino continues his career trend, and hits the DL again, Hosmer and Moustakis struggle, and the team nestles in with the Twins at the bottom of the division.

Bottom Line:

This team is not deep enough to contend for a playoff spot. Once again, look for the Royals to be mathematically eliminated from playoff contention relatively early in the year.

Minnesota Twins

MVP: Byron Buxton

The years of the Twins perennially being in the playoff hunt are over. This team is bad. Really bad. So bad, in fact that no regular player deserves the MVP. So, why not give it to 2nd overall pick Byron Buxton. This kid could be the face of the franchise in a couple years. Let’s give him some props now.

Best Case Scenario:

The team moves a couple veterans for prospects, and sets themselves up nicely to draft high next year. This team is in rebuilding mode, so the goal should really be to set up some pieces for the future.

Worst Case Scenario:

The team goes on a mid-to-late season run, puts themselves in playoff contention, but just misses out. They hold on to some vets thinking they can squeak into the playoffs, and end up wasting a rebuilding year. Don’t worry this team isn’t talented enough to be in contention.

Bottom Line:

More of the same. It could be a long season, Twins fans.

Don't expect to see this scene at Target Field much in 2012

No comments:

Post a Comment